6. Shelter & Camp Setup

Backpacks

6d.
Tell the difference between internal- and external-frame packs. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of each.

Your backpack is the piece of gear that carries everything else. Choosing the right type of pack affects your comfort, balance, and how much you can bring. There are two main categories: internal-frame and external-frame packs.

External-Frame Packs

An external-frame pack has a rigid frame (usually aluminum) on the outside, with a fabric bag attached to it. The frame is visible, and gear can be lashed to the frame itself.

Advantages:

  • Ventilation — The frame holds the pack away from your back, creating an air gap that keeps you cooler. This is a significant advantage on hot days.
  • Load organization — The rigid frame makes it easy to organize and access gear. You can strap bulky items (like a sleeping bag or tent) directly to the outside of the frame.
  • Affordability — External-frame packs are generally less expensive than comparably sized internal-frame packs.
  • Upright posture — The frame distributes weight high, which encourages a more upright walking posture and works well on maintained trails.

Disadvantages:

  • Less stable — The high center of gravity makes external frames less stable on rough, uneven terrain. You may feel more “sway” when scrambling over rocks or crossing streams.
  • Snag hazard — The rigid frame and external gear can catch on branches, rocks, and brush during off-trail travel.
  • Heavier — The metal frame adds weight compared to modern internal-frame designs.
  • Less comfortable on technical terrain — On steep or uneven ground, the pack does not move with your body as naturally.

Internal-Frame Packs

An internal-frame pack hides its support structure inside the pack bag. Lightweight aluminum stays or a plastic framesheet provide rigidity, but the pack sits closer to your body and moves with you.

Advantages:

  • Stability — The pack hugs your body and keeps the weight close to your center of gravity. This is a huge advantage on rough terrain, steep trails, and when scrambling.
  • Streamlined profile — No external frame to snag on branches or rocks. Better for bushwhacking and off-trail travel.
  • Lighter — Modern internal-frame packs use lightweight materials and minimal framing, saving weight.
  • Versatility — Internal-frame packs are available in a wide range of sizes and configurations, from ultralight daypacks to expedition-size haulers.

Disadvantages:

  • Less ventilation — The pack sits against your back, which means more sweat on hot days. Some models use suspended mesh back panels to improve airflow, but they still run warmer than external frames.
  • Harder to organize — Without the rigid external frame, gear can shift inside the pack. Packing efficiently takes more practice.
  • Cost — Quality internal-frame packs tend to be more expensive than external-frame options.

Which One Should You Choose?

FactorExternal FrameInternal Frame
Trail typeMaintained trailsAny terrain
WeatherBest in hot weather (ventilation)Works in all weather
Load weightHandles heavy loads wellHandles moderate to heavy loads
StabilityLess stable off-trailVery stable
PriceGenerally lowerGenerally higher
Best forSummer car camping, trail hikesBackpacking, rugged terrain
  • Trail type

    External Frame
    Maintained trails
    Internal Frame
    Any terrain
  • Weather

    External Frame
    Best in hot weather (ventilation)
    Internal Frame
    Works in all weather
  • Load weight

    External Frame
    Handles heavy loads well
    Internal Frame
    Handles moderate to heavy loads
  • Stability

    External Frame
    Less stable off-trail
    Internal Frame
    Very stable
  • Price

    External Frame
    Generally lower
    Internal Frame
    Generally higher
  • Best for

    External Frame
    Summer car camping, trail hikes
    Internal Frame
    Backpacking, rugged terrain
Two backpacks standing side by side outdoors: an external-frame pack with visible aluminum frame on the left, and a modern internal-frame pack on the right, both loaded for a camping trip

Pack Fit Basics

  • Torso length matters more than your height. Measure from your C7 vertebra (the bump at the base of your neck) to the top of your hip bones.
  • Hip belt should sit on top of your hip bones, not your waist. This is where 60–70% of the pack weight should rest.
  • Shoulder straps should wrap over your shoulders and connect to the pack about 2 inches below the tops of your shoulders.
  • Load lifter straps (the small straps that angle from the top of the shoulder straps to the top of the pack) should be angled at about 45 degrees.
How to Choose a Backpack
A Scout wearing a properly fitted internal-frame backpack from the side, with labels pointing to the hip belt, shoulder straps, load lifters, and sternum strap